

After a midterm defeat, Trump stood beside Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin. Was this diplomacy—or a performance of presidential power?
The photographs tells a story.
There they stood in Shenzhen, China: Donald Trump, Xi Jinping, and Vladimir Putin.
Three presidents. Three nuclear powers. Two authoritarian rulers. And one American president whose party had just suffered a devastating midterm election defeat. Trump learned that in a democracy, its the citizens that determine the fate of its leaders. To this day, Trump doesn’t realize that most Americans rejected him and his government. Welcome to a democracy, Donald.
The summit was called historic. The leaders discussed peace, nuclear security, and international cooperation.
But something was missing.
Ukraine

Russia’s invasion produced no ceasefire, no withdrawal, and no enforceable peace agreement. Instead, the world received a carefully staged photograph of three powerful men celebrating their importance.
Perhaps that was the point.
The shadow of the midterms
Just weeks earlier, American voters had rejected Trump’s party, weakening his political standing.
Did the election influence his appearance in China?
We cannot know. The summit was planned earlier. But the timing raises questions.
A president weakened at home may seek strength abroad. International summits provide ceremonies, flags, cameras, and declarations of greatness.
For Trump, appearing alongside Xi and Putin offered an opportunity to project authority.
At home, voters had challenged his power. In a massive display termed a Blue Tsunami, states around the country decimated republican control of House districts, Senate representation, and state governments. I wrote about how John Ossoff and Keisha Lance Bottoms led the way to turn the state blue. If you go to this link will see how the Democrats changed the politics in Georgia for the next two years. It was a remarkable result.
Abroad, two authoritarian leaders welcomed him.
Was this diplomacy serving America’s interests—or Trump’s political image?
Putin’s diplomatic victory
Putin may have benefited most.
The Russian president invaded Ukraine in 2022, unleashing a devastating war. Yet in Shenzhen, he stood beside the American president as a respected participant in discussions about peace.
The aggressor was welcomed. The invaded country was absent. Zelensky calls Putin a ‘killer’ as he slams Trump’s ‘friendship’ with Moscow. Putin offered no meaningful concessions. But he gained something valuable: international legitimacy.
Xi also benefited. Hosting the gathering reinforced China’s position as a global power.
Together, the three leaders projected a world where powerful nations negotiate arrangements while smaller countries remain outside the room.
Democracy and the politics of power
The summit exposed competing visions of leadership.
Democracy requires accountability to voters, courts, legislatures, and constitutional restraints.
Authoritarianism concentrates power in individual rulers.
That distinction matters after the midterms. Americans exercised their democratic authority to limit Trump’s power. Xi and Putin face no comparable electoral accountability.
Diplomacy with adversaries is necessary. But meetings should produce more than photographs and declarations.
What did America gain? What did Ukraine gain?
The answers remain troublingly unclear.
Democracy requires more than powerful men making promises. It requires accountability, sovereignty, and the courage to defend principles—even when dictators are sitting across the table.
Keeping Watch | Reflections on democracy, power, and the responsibilities of citizenship

You must be logged in to post a comment.