Corporate Reform Movement Cause of Atlanta Cheating Scandal

Written by Jack Hassard

On July 12, 2011

As stated in the Governor’s  Investigative Report a “culture of fear” took over the Atlanta School System, and led to a conspiracy of silence which enabled the bubble sheet erasure scandle to happen.

But in the last two posts I have opened the door to examine causes that go beyond the Atlanta School District.  The Governor’s report offered three reasons why cheating occurred (p. 350, Volume 3).

  • The targets set by the district were often unrealistic, especially given their cumulative effect over the years. Additionally, the administration put unreasonable pressure on teachers and principals to achieve targets.
  • A culture of fear, intimidation and retaliation spread throughout the district.
  • Dr. Hall and her administration emphasized test results and public praise to the exclusion of integrity and ethics.

One statement in the report that is interesting in the context of this post: “APS is indeed a “data driven system,” and whether or not a school meets targets is the most important data of all” (Volume 3, p. 355).  Yet is does not go on a ask why.  The answer is simple.  The State Department of Education is “data driven,” and if you don’t believe me, please go to this page, and you will be able to access hundreds of Excel Spreadsheets showing the data the state uses to determine whether a school and its district has reached targets set by the state.  And much of this mind-set can be traced back to the NCLB Act which has set the target that 100% of students will be proficient in reading, language arts, and math.

The Corporate Take Over of the Nation's Schools

The mess we are in could be do to a “corporate reform movement” that has as its backers a billionaire club of investors, businesses, and corporate “charities” that have poured billions of dollars into funding charter schools, the Common Core Standards, and the forthcoming set of end-of-year tests designed to measure the Common Core Standards.

Months ago the film Waiting for Superman was released (See trailer here.) The Guggenheim film, which touts the efforts of a school in New York that was funded by corporate giants to the tune of millions of dollars, and pits public school teachers as the agents of evil, against the “good guys” that teach in charter/private schools.  The film is more propaganda, and is based not on any research, but on a preconceived notion that our public schools are failing, and that the way to save them is look for superman.  Behind most charter schools, such as the Kipp Foundation, are foundations and corporations, and indeed Wall Street investors, who see a quick return on investment in schools that have not been shown to be any more effective than public schools.

As one educator in Chicago suggested, do we want the business model that caused the Great Recession to take over and be the model of schooling.  Slowly, but surely, this same business model has become the reform movement of those in power—governors, corporate heads, wealthy foundations.

Waiting for Superman was the Corporate Reform Movement’s theme song.  Now, at last, a film has appeared that questions the corporate model, and suggests that citizens, parents, and teachers offer quite a different picture and it has been captured in the film The Inconvenient Truth Behind Waiting for Superman.”  Take a look at this trailer for the movie.

The film premiered recently in New York City, in this video, you can see footage from that premiere, and what some of the viewers had to say.

 

 

You May Also Like…

Beyond the Scientific Method by Charles R. Ault

Beyond the Scientific Method by Charles R. Ault

The guest post by Dr. Charles Ault, an Emeritus Professor of science education, challenges the current scientific educational approach. He critiques the traditional “unity” view that suggests science processes are universally applicable across all scientific disciplines. Dr. Ault advocates for recognizing the diversity and uniqueness of methods within each scientific discipline. He demonstrates this using examples of how geology and physics operate uniquely. He also introduces his concept of “scientific diversity,” which emphasizes that the interpretation and implementation of core scientific ideas should be adaptable to the specific discipline they are applied to. Furthermore, he suggests rethinking the traditional scientific method and adapting it to the disciplinary contexts.

Beyond Science Standards

Beyond Science Standards

I want to tell you about a book that was just published in the field of science education. It’s a book that I was asked to write the forward. I’ve never been asked to write a forward for a book. But I was honored, and I want to encourage you to examine this book, whether you are a science educator, a scientist or a citizen interested in public education.

A Letter from A Teen Living in 2051 about Education and the Climate Crisis

A Letter from A Teen Living in 2051 about Education and the Climate Crisis

This post focuses on education and climate as seen by a teen living in Atlanta in the year 2051.  I originally published it on April 21,  2012.  Although a work of fiction, it is presented here as a reminder of the consequences of making decisions based on faulty reasoning and ignorance.  I am re-publishing it today ahead of the 2021 United Nations Climate Change Conference being held in Glasgow, Scotland

0 Comments

We would enjoy reading your comments

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from Citizen Jack

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading